First widespread occurrence of rare phosphate chladniite in a meteorite, winonaite Graves Nunataks (GRA) 12510: Implications for phosphide–phosphate redox buffered genesis in meteoritesOPEN ACCESS
Brendan A. Anzures, Francis M. McCubbin, Timmons M. Erickson, Ryan S. Jakubek, Marc D. Fries, Loan Le
American Mineralogist (2024) 109 (9): 1513–1522
1 September 2024
“The first widespread occurrence of rare Na-, Ca-, and Mg, Mn, Fe-bearing phosphate chladniite was observed in meteorite Graves Nunataks (GRA) 12510, which is a primitive achondrite that sits within the winonaite class. Numerous 1–500 µm chladniite grains were found, often on the margins between silicate clasts and the kamacite portions of the large metal veins that permeated through the sample. The largest chladniite grains are associated with merrillite, kamacite, taenite, troilite, albite, forsterite, diopside, and enstatite, with a few tiny chladniite grains and an apatite grain enclosed within merrillite. GRA 12510s average chladniite composition is Na2.7Ca1.25(Mg10.02Mn0.69Fe0.20)Σ10.91(PO4)9. Electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD) patterns indicate varying degrees of nucleation and growth of chladniite grains. Additionally, the first pure Raman spectrum of chladniite is described here, revealing primary ν1 bands at 954, 974, and especially 984 cm–1. The co-occurrence and close association of merrillite, apatite, chladniite, and P-bearing metallic phases within GRA 12510 suggests that the fO2 of IW-2 to IW-4 is an intrinsic property of the precursor chondritic material, and the phosphate-phosphide reaction may have buffered the final winonaite and IAB iron meteorite phase assemblages. Altogether, chladniite appears to form alongside other phosphates, with their chemistries reflecting the diverse environment of their formation. Meteoritic chladniite likely formed through subsolidus oxidation of schreibersite, scavenging Na from albite, Ca from diopside, Mg from enstatite/forsterite, Fe from kamacite/taenite, and Mn from alabandite/chromite when available. A P0-P5+ redox-buffered environment also has implications for thermometry and fast cooling rates, although more experiments are needed to extrapolate powder reaction rates to those of larger crystals. Furthermore, phosphide-phosphate buffered experiments may aid in investigating equilibrium chemistry at fO2 values between IW-2 and IW-4, which have been challenging to explore experimentally due to the limited availability of solid metal-metal oxide buffers between IW (Fe-FeO) and IW-5 (Cr-Cr2O3) at temperatures and pressures relevant to planetary interiors. Future investigations of phosphide-phosphate redox-buffered genesis at fO2 values between IW-2 and IW-4 have important implications for primitive meteorite constituents (e.g., CAI values), partially differentiated planetesimals and planets, including Mercury and core formation on Earth.”
