A statistical investigation into relationships between the IIE irons and the ordinary, F and “HH” chondritesOPEN ACCESS 

· by · in , , , , , , , ,

Rachel S. Kirby, Penelope L. King, Andrew G. Tomkins

MAPS, Version of Record online: 05 September 2025

LINK (OPEN ACCESS)
PDF (OPEN ACCESS)

“It has been proposed that IIE iron meteorites formed through impact processes on a parent body that was composed of either the H chondrites or a much-debated fourth ordinary chondrite group, the HH chondrites. To resolve this debate, we have compiled a large dataset for the ordinary chondrites, low-fayalite ungrouped chondrites, and IIE irons, and undertaken a statistical analysis to determine if: (1) the current classification of ordinary chondrite groups is statistically appropriate; and (2) the IIE irons are related to H chondrites or if they represent a distinct group that formed on a “HH” chondrite parent body. We demonstrate that the current classification system based on petrography and olivine and orthopyroxene chemistry is appropriate for the H, L, and LL chondrites. We define a fourth “F chondrite” group consisting of eight, previously ungrouped, very low-Fa Type 3 and 4 chondrites. Statistical analysis of Δ17O data alone cannot distinguish between the H chondrites and IIE irons, nor between the L and LL chondrites. Furthermore, statistical analyses are unable to distinguish H chondrites from IIE irons in all measures (mineral chemistry, chondrule size, bulk Δ17O, Ge and Mo isotopic compositions, and bulk siderophile element abundances in metal); there is no evidence for a “HH” chondrite group. These results are consistent with formation of IIE iron meteorites through impact melting and near-surface metal segregation on the H chondrite parent body. This genetic link between H chondrites and IIE irons allows us to understand the geochemical and petrological changes that occurred during planetary formation and evolution.”

Related posts (automatically generated):

  1. Formation, cooling history and age of impact events on the IIE iron parent body: evidence from the Miles meteorite
  2. IIE irons: Origin, relationship to ordinary chondrites, and evidence for siderophile-element fractionations caused by chondrule formation
  3. Results of statistical analysis of primary components concentrations in bulk chemical composition of ordinary chondrite groups
  4. Geochemical evidence for the origin of the IIE parent body from H chondrite-like material
  5. In-situ formation of halite in the Sidi El Habib 001 (H5) ordinary chondrite: Implications for hydrothermal alteration in ordinary chondrite parent bodies
  6. A statistical analysis of the H/L ratio of ordinary chondrite finds and falls: A comparison of Oman finds with other populations
  7. Planetary Genealogy of Iron Meteorites and Pallasites Using ε54Cr-Δ17O Isotope Systematics
  8. Constraints on asteroid magnetic field evolution and the radii of meteorite parent bodies from thermal modelling
  9. Meteorite evidence for partial differentiation and protracted accretion of planetesimalsOPEN ACCESS 
  10. Siderophile element and Hf-W isotope characteristics of the metal-rich chondrite NWA 12273 – Implication for its origin and chondrite metal formation
Tags: , , , , , , ,